How to scale a trie across multiple servers

Katedral Pillon

Does anyone know how I might scale a Trie across multiple machines? Say the first machine runs out of space and I need to add more words from a very large dictionary, what might I do to add more words? (I am a Java thinker, but I believe the answer can be language agnostic). I have already realized that I cannot just say one machine for each first character, but that doesn't really scale.

peter

Ok, given the assumption, that both of your machines have the same resources available, let’s first look at a simpler example:

how would you scale a binary tree? Or even better - an AVL tree? There are several examples to do this:

  1. If there would be only 2 machines and storage is your problem, I’d keep the root and the left subtree on one machine, and send the right subtree to the other.
  2. If you’d have 3 machines and would also want to have a load balancer, the root would stay on one machine and the left and right subtree would be split accross the other 2 machines. If you have 5 you keep the root and first level of children on the load balancer and split the rest of the tree.

(note that balancing such a distributed tree will be much more complicated, as you’ll need to communicate with other machines and do it possibly inside a distributed transaction, to be able to answer all requests concurrently)

So, now a trie, which - AFAIR - is a tree / letter. If the letters in your words would be distributed evenly, you could have A-M on one machine and N-Z on the other. This will probably not work, but you’ll for sure be able to split it more or less 50/50 like this.

If you now want to add more and more machines, I’d keep a main node which would work as a load balancer and distribute it to the child nodes, which would only take care of few letters. For instance you could have nodes

  • A-F
  • G-M
  • N-R
  • S
  • T-Z

Assuming, you have roughly as much data for the letters A-F as you have for the letter S. (There actually might be a language, where this would be at least close to the most optimal distribution)

Now if you get too many letters in A-F you can just split it into A-D and E-F for instance, nothing really changes there. The problem will be if you’d get too many letters in S. Now you’d have 3 possibilities:

  1. You make another load balancer for the letter S - this will be for sure easy, as you already have a load balancer implemented and you can use the same functionality on any level
  2. You keep letters SA-SM (for instance) in one node, which will be the main node, store SN-SZ on a separate node. So if you get SP.. the first load balancer would send it to your SA-SM node and that one would forward it to SN-SZ
  3. You modify the load root load balancer to be able to specify more complex boundaries between nodes, such as you’d have now the nodes

    • A-F
    • G-M
    • N-R
    • SA-SM
    • SN-SZ
    • T-Z

Here number 1 is probably the easiest and cleanest solution, but might have some unused hardware. In case you can use different resources for nodes, option 1 with a small load balancer for the letter S would be probably the way to go. Option 2 is a dirty mix, and option 3 might be the nicest way to go, but it makes the load balancer potentially complicated and error prone.

Hope this ideas help you.

Collected from the Internet

Please contact [email protected] to delete if infringement.

edited at
0

Comments

0 comments
Login to comment

Related

How to manage websockets across multiple servers / workers

MySQL database across multiple servers

R: how to make the same scale for dots across multiple dotplots

How do git servers scale?

Generate unique ID across multiple independent servers

Java: synchronizing threads across multiple servers

Synchronized script execution across multiple servers

Scaling Socket.IO across multiple servers

Synchronization xml file across multiple servers(machine)

Shared Varnish cache across multiple servers

Using sed command in for loop across multiple servers

How to deploy a distributed system across multiple servers in parallel using VSTS release process

How to store socket.id across multiple servers nodejs and socket.io

How can I quickly distribute files equally across multiple partitions / servers?

How to store data for a user across servers discord

Spring batch restrict single instance of job across multiple servers

Laravel Task Scheduler across multiple servers without overlap

Submitting "ps" across multiple servers, output going to one text file

Golang file and folder replication / mirroring across multiple servers

Using Quartz to Schedule Single Job Across Multiple Stateless App Servers

Proper way distribute several scientific experiments across multiple servers?

Get-ADUser for multiple users across different servers

Distributing a Neo4j Graph Across Multiple Servers

Mass deployment of package to multiple Linux servers across different continents

How to align scale transformation across geoms?

How to use SignalR on multiple servers?

How to proxy to multiple servers in WebSocket

How to run multiple js servers

Can Azure Website scale across multiple availability zones